Why don't impressions mean anyone remembers you?
In the article about the gorilla half of people miss, I wrote about the doorman in your head. Every ad has to climb four floors: contact, noticing, conscious perception and a lasting impression. According to an estimate by Ed Papazian of Media Dynamics (2014), out of 362 daily ad contacts, 12 leave any impression at all.
Impressions are the first floor. They count how many times an ad appeared on a screen. Not whether anyone looked at it. Not whether they knew whose ad it was. And certainly not whether they'll recall it a month later.
Now add attention. Research by FOX, the Wharton Neuroscience Initiative and Bill Harvey Consulting (2024) found that social platforms and short-form video keep most ad exposures under two seconds of real attention. Two seconds can remind people who already know a brand. It rarely persuades someone new. According to the same research, it takes around 15 seconds for people to warm to a brand.
So a million impressions in a report is an impressive number. It's just that nobody remembers a thing.
Why can't you measure brand like performance?
Because each one lives on a different clock.
A performance campaign (ads built for clicks and purchases) works on people who already want to buy. You see the effect within days. Brand works on people who'll buy in six months, in a year, or when their washing machine breaks. British researchers Les Binet and Peter Field showed across hundreds of campaigns that short-term and long-term effects hand over somewhere between 3 and 12 months. Emotional brand campaigns beat rational sales campaigns once you measure them over more than about six months. Ideally a year or longer.
From my own experience, a brand campaign pays back in 8 to 12 months. Judge it after a week, and all you've measured is that it isn't ripe yet.
The strongest data on this comes from the UK's Thinkbox. Marek Singer, head of strategy at Prima Group, pointed me to their studies in a LinkedIn discussion. Profit Ability 2 (Thinkbox, Ebiquity and EffWorks, 2024) analyzed £1.8 billion of media investment across 141 brands, 14 categories and 10 media types:
| When you measure | Profit returned per £1 of advertising |
| First 13 weeks | £1.87 |
| Total over 0–24 months | £4.11 |
So 58% of advertising profit arrived after the first 13 weeks. Measure only the first quarter, and you're seeing less than half the result.
To be fair: Thinkbox is the marketing body for UK commercial TV. The study comes from an industry with an interest in showing what TV can do. But the methodology (econometric models by Ebiquity) is publicly described, and the timing finding is backed by Binet and Field, who don't work for TV.
| Performance | Brand |
| What you measure | Clicks, conversions, cost per customer | Reach, attention, recall, searches for your name |
| When you see results | Days to weeks | Months to years |
| Who you're talking to | People who already want to buy | Everyone who will buy someday |
| Typical mistake | Takes credit for customers who'd have come anyway | Gets measured on clicks, so it "didn't do anything" |
What to measure instead of impressions
Here are six metrics that show your brand honestly. Two of them are free and take five minutes.
- Unique reach and frequency. Not how many times the ad was shown, but how many different people saw it, and how many times on average. A million impressions could be 500,000 people seeing it twice, or 50,000 people who've seen you twenty times and now can't stand you.
- Attention. How many seconds people actually looked at the ad. Specialized tools measure this today (attention metrics). If you don't have them, at least track video watch time and completion rate.
- How many people search for your name. In Google Search Console, filter queries that contain your company name and look at the trend over the last 16 months. In Google Trends, compare your name with competitors. Les Binet showed that share of search moves like market share, just ahead of it. Free, five minutes.
- Awareness and recall (brand lift). A short survey before and after the campaign: "Which companies in this category can you name?" (unaided awareness) and "Do you know this brand?" (aided awareness). Big platforms (Meta, YouTube) offer brand lift studies for larger campaigns.
- Share of voice versus market share. When your advertising is more visible than your market share would suggest, you have what's called excess share of voice. According to Binet and Field, 10 extra points bring roughly half a percentage point of market share growth per year on average. When you're less visible than your share, you slowly lose it.
- Price and margin. The quietest proof of a strong brand: you can charge more and customers stay. If you constantly have to discount to sell, your brand isn't doing its job.
One bonus metric if you have a physical store: ask at the register, "How did you hear about us?" Write the answers down. In three months, you'll know more than any impressions report could tell you.
How to explain it to your CFO
Now the half of the blame I promised at the start. CFOs ask about clicks because we've been bringing them clicks for years. When the headline number in a brand campaign report is impressions, they do the only logical thing: they look for what came of them. And find very little.
My advice (more in the article on how much CFO a CMO needs to have in them):
- Agree up front, not after the campaign. Before you put the first dollar into brand, write down together what you'll measure and when. No impressions as the headline number.
- Report in two lanes. The short lane (weeks): performance, clicks, cost per customer. The long lane (quarters): searches for your name, awareness, share of voice, price.
- Give it the time it needs. For brand, plan on an 8 to 12 month horizon. Judging it earlier is like judging an apple tree in March.
- Show what brand does for performance. When searches for your name go up, cost per customer in your performance campaigns usually goes down. A CFO gets that instantly, because it shows up in their spreadsheet.
Expert perspective: "Impressions are the receipt for what you paid. Not proof that anyone remembers you. If you put millions of impressions as the headline number in a brand report, you asked for the question about clicks," says Michal Krčmář, founder of Don Marketer and a CMO with nearly two decades of experience in global marketing.
For a hair salon: measuring your brand is simpler than you think. How many new clients a month tell you "a friend told me about you"? How many people search Google for your salon's name directly (you'll see it in your Google Business Profile)? And after a year, can you raise your prices by five dollars without anyone leaving? Three numbers, zero impressions.
For a corporation in Miami: make share of search a monthly leadership metric and run brand tracking at least once a quarter. Leave impressions to your agency as an operational number for media optimization. They don't belong in the board report.
The takeaway
"So how many clicks did it bring in?" Today I'd answer that question differently than I used to. Not by defending impressions. With a chart where the number of people searching for our name goes up, and right next to it, cost per customer goes down. That's a language both marketing and finance speak.
A test for tonight: open Google Search Console, filter queries with your company name and look at the last 16 months. Is the line going up? Then your brand is working, even if you can't see it in impressions. Flat? Then you know where to start.
And if you're figuring out how much of your budget should go to brand versus performance, the Don Marketer calculator works out the split for your company stage and industry in 2 minutes.
Sources: Ebiquity: Profit Ability 2 – The new business case for advertising (Thinkbox, Ebiquity, EffWorks, 2024; £1.8bn, 141 brands, 14 categories); Thinkbox: Profit Ability 2; Will Patrick: The Long and the Short of It – summary (Binet & Field, IPA, 2013; timing of effects, ESOV); MediaVillage: Two Seconds of Ad Exposure Insufficient for Brand Growth (FOX, Wharton Neuroscience Initiative, Bill Harvey Consulting, 2024); IPA: The Long and the Short of It (presentation); Les Binet, share of search as a predictor of market share (IPA, 2020); Ed Papazian, Media Dynamics (2014); the author's own experience.